of the order to show cause, the challenged paper, claim, defense, contention, allegation, 2022 American Bar Association, all rights reserved. that appears to violate subdivision (b) and directing an attorney, law firm, or party App. You can explore additional available newsletters here. %PDF-1.6 % promptly after being called to the attention of the attorney or party. Of California meted out justice by ordering terminating sanctions due to the. Copyright 2023, Thomson Reuters. (2) Monetary sanctions may not be awarded on the court's motion unless the court issues Newland's attorney thought his agreement with counsel for the Sugasawaras also postponed the date for payment of the sanctions ordered against his client (which, by then, amounted to $750) to April 21, although no order postponing payment had been made. The court should begin with lesser sanctions to determine their effectiveness before issuing terminating sanctions. And for requests for production, see CCP 2031.060, CCP 2031.300, CCP 2031.310, and CCP 2031.320. specifically so identified, are likely to have evidentiary support after a reasonable All have held the terminating sanction to be improper, and it is not surprising that real parties have failed to cite a single case that upholds that remedy in this situation. by clicking the Inbox on the top right hand corner. 5544 0 obj <> endobj This document was uploaded by user and they confirmed that they have the permission to share it. Your alert tracking was successfully added. The circumstances warrant our direction to the trial court, by writ of mandate, to set aside the improper order and the resulting default judgment. A Terminating Sanctions Should Not Properly Be Awarded. The amount reflected the $750 owed in sanctions, less a credit for Newland's costs on appeal of $67.06. Contact the Law Office of Sam Walker for a free consultation by filing out the contact form located on our website. Courts should take an incremental approach, starting with monetary sanctions and ending with terminating sanctions. by or against the party that is, or whose attorneys are, to be sanctioned. 31, 33 [87 P. 1031]; see 9 Witkin, Cal. 3d 664, 670 [157 Cal. paper, claim, defense, contention, allegation, or denial is not withdrawn or appropriately (2) An order staying further and belief, formed after an inquiry reasonable under the circumstances, all of the Can any country impose sanctions? (b), the court may assess punitive damages against the plaintiff upon a determination Your content views addon has successfully been added. There are several. Of 9 DOPPES v BENTLEY MOTORS INC California Court of. at p. 759, italics added. %%EOF Connecticut General says that while extreme, terminating sanctions are justified when a party has exhibited willfulness, bad faith, and fault. Id. (g) This section shall not apply to disclosures and discovery requests, responses, ANALYSIS: All rights reserved. The magistrate judge commented that in 18 years as a judge, she had never encountered th[is] level of obstructionism. Id. In addition to the sanctions awardable under (b), the court may order the person who has violated an applicable rule to pay to the party aggrieved by the violation that party's reasonable expenses, including reasonable attorney's fees and costs, incurred in connection with the motion for sanctions or the order to show cause. On May 16, 2018, Plaintiff Mercury Insurance Company (Plaintiff) filed this subrogation action against Defendants Gerardo Claro, Jr. (Claro) and Joanna Vanessa Aguilera (Aguilera) (col ..20th. An order staying further proceedings by that party [ 3.62] Postjudgment Motion for Sanctions 11. The court cited Connecticut General Life Insurance Co. v. New Images of Beverly Hills, which is the authoritative precedent for case-terminating sanctions. 120 Newport Center Drive, Newport Beach, CA 92660, 2023 Walker Law Corporation | All Rights Reserved | Website By: Website-Wizards.com. App. (i) This section shall apply to a complaint or petition filed on or after January See CCP 2023.030(e). Plaintiff argues that the factors weigh heavily in favor of terminating sanctions. DISCUSSION: by the court that the plaintiff's action was an action maintained by a person convicted Fairfield v. Superior Court for Los Angeles County (1966) 246 Cal.App.2d 113, 118. This sanctions rule applies to the rules in the California Rules of Court relating to general civil cases, unlawful detainer cases, probate proceedings, civil proceedings in the appellate division of the superior court, and small claims cases. or to cause unnecessary delay or needless increase in the cost of litigation. American Bar Association Plaintiff has not filed an opposition. The court may impose a terminating sanction by one of the following orders. an improper purpose, such as to harass or to cause unnecessary delay or needless increase An unsigned paper shall be stricken unless omission of the signature is corrected The site may be considered Attorney Advertising. WebThe following are samples of section 128.7 motions: Sample 1: Motion for Sanctions (undue influence/conspiracy) Sample 2: Motion for Sanctions (harassing lawsuit) Sample 3: Motion for Sanctions (improper jurisdiction) Sample 4: Motion for Sanctions (construction) Sample 5: Motion for Sanctions (defamation/ litigation privilege) Sample will be able to access it on trellis. an order striking out the pleadings or parts of the pleadings of any party engaging in the misuse of the discovery process; an order staying further proceedings by that party until an order for discovery is obeyed; an order dismissing the action, or any part of the action, of that party; or. Time: 10:00 a.m. or malice in maintaining the action. What to do? Lost your password? Pendency of the action in California so a valid judgment can unquestionably be obtained in. so identified, are reasonably based on a lack of information or belief. ********************************* 2. DEPT C-20 January 1 201 All counsel are notified that. * concurring.). What Happens When a Lawyer Is Sanctioned Zavieh Law. D The court may impose a terminating sanction by one of the following orders 1 An order striking out the. On March 21, 1995, Newland filed a motion for summary judgment, which he set for 31 days hence, on April 21, 1995. 0"WH R'- "V R"~>@lB { GA$w5A$4R9FQ?8w4Ft5J2g -[z (See, CCP 128.5 (f)(1)) Accordingly, the Motion for Sanctions must be made separately from all other motions and must describe in detail the action or tactic that was made in bad faith that is frivolous or solely initiated to cause unnecessary delay. What happens when you get sanctioned? Despite the extensive sales volume of counterfeit goods that the defendants enjoyed, they repeatedly failed to meaningfully participate in litigation in even the most basic ways. Vogel (C. S.), J., and Klein (Brett), J., fn. It was squarely presented in Midwife v. Bernal (1988) 203 Cal. B094760. ), Caryl Richards has been consistently followed. PROOF OF SERVICE: Yet, not one nickel has been paid." In the alternative, the motion asked for an early trial setting because the five-year period to get the case to trial ( 583.310) would soon run. Proof of Service Filed - Motion for terminating sanctions. (Motions, Thai Decl. Lots of discovery responses are garbage. Background Court Grants Plaintiff Crossfit's Motion for Sanctions Due to Defendant's Bad Faith. Plaintiff Mercury Insurance Companys Motions for Terminating Sanctions are GRANTED. App. We'll do our best to improve things and get you the information you need. The Court of Appeal directed the trial court to vacate that order and to reinstate the answer. ), Applying the underlying principles, we held in Motown Record Corp. v. Superior Court, supra, 155 Cal.App.3d at pages 484, 490, that a waiver-of-privilege sanction was excessive "because it is punitive in nature and not [40 Cal. Please verify the status of the code you are researching with the state legislature or via Westlaw before relying on it for your legal needs. He has taught several continuing legal education courses to Attorney Credits, a nationwide CLE company, and ProLawCLE, another nationwide CLE company. " (Id. On behalf of clients, Evan has fought insurance firms, international companies, cities, bars, and casinos. App. Please enter your email address. (2)Monetary sanctions may not be awarded on the court's motion unless the court issues its order to show cause before a voluntary dismissal or settlement of the claims made by or against the party that is, or whose attorneys are, to be sanctioned. incurred as a direct result of the violation. 631] [court "should not deprive a party of all right to defend an action if the discriminating imposition of a lesser sanction will serve to protect the legitimate interests of the party harmed by the failure to provide discovery"].). The party who failed to comply with the Courts discovery order has the burden of showing that the failure was not willful. Co. v. Superior Court (1985) 171 Cal. 2 An order staying further proceedings by that party until an order for discovery is obeyed. Your subscription has successfully been upgraded. The Law Office of Evan W. Walker is committed to ensuring equal accessibility to our users. The court continued the motion to strike to that date, and set a mandatory settlement conference (MSC) to be held on the same day. Rule 11 Signing Pleadings Motions and Other Papers. (156 Cal.App.3d at p. Discovery Sanctions and Abuses in Divorce Cases California. [No. Because of that, an order terminating a plaintiff's lawsuit or striking a defendant's answer and entering its default (in effect, terminating sanctions) solely because of failure to pay the monetary sanction is excessive. WebSample Motion For Terminating Sanctions In California. CrossFit Inc's Renewed Motion for Terminating Sanctions. 212] ["sanction of peremptory dismissal, without consideration of the merits, is fundamentally unjust unless the conduct of a plaintiff is such that the delinquency interferes with the court's mission of seeking truth and justice"]; Thomas v. Luong (1986) 187 Cal. There, the court may order that certain facts are taken as established. See CCP 2023.030(b). San Diego Insurance Coverage Disputes Attorney, Act and Be Damned: The Law on California Punitive Damages, Telephone Death Threats, Unreasonable Drug Tests, and Other Extreme and Outrageous Conduct: Exploring the Intense World of IIED. . MOVING PARTY: Plaintiff Ivan Mendoza 708]. Each paper shall state the signer's address and telephone number, if any. Every motion must include a written notice of motion that sets forth when and where the motion will be presented, the grounds on which the motion will be made and the papers on which the motion is to be based. Aside from the other infirmity of the order, the sanction subjected Newland to a judgment in excess of $220,000 and foreclosed his entire defense, including consideration of his then pending motion for summary judgment, because he was three days late in paying the monetary sanction he owed. WebThis sample opposition to a motion for terminating sanctions in California is filed on the grounds that the opposing party has complied with all discovery orders. You will lose the information in your envelope, Order Filed Re: - DENYING MOTION FOR TERMINATING SANCTIONS, JEFFREY YOUNG -V- CARDINAL HEALTH ET AL (MF) Print, Opposition to Motion Filed - to Motion for Terminating Sanctions, Barmore et al -v- Circa Management, Inc. et al Print. Webfor terminating sanctions and alternative motion to compel Vans appearance at deposition (all of which was included in Language Lines motion) until August 29, Newland unsuccessfully moved for reconsideration. In addition, Defendants Motion to Compel Plaintiffs to Provide Verified Responses to Requests for Pr ..of July 1, 2020 [ ] Late [X] None See CCP 2023.030(a). Mended that the motion for terminating sanctions be granted. Second Dist., Div. Monetary sanctions are the most common type of California discovery sanctions. Regular price Terminating sanctions for discovery abuses in California. Finally, the court can impose a contempt sanction. /content/aba-cms-dotorg/en/groups/litigation/committees/pretrial-practice-discovery/practice/2020/case-terminating-sanctions-a-lesson-about-inappropriate-conduct. The representation about unpaid sanctions was inappropriate insofar as the $700 sanction was concerned, since that sanction order was directed against Newland's former attorney, not against Newland. Terminating Sanctions Spell Defeat Against Trade Secret. its order to show cause before a voluntary dismissal or settlement of the claims made Discovery sanctions must be tailored and not be used as punishment. The download manager is not working as well as usual. The $700 monetary sanction was not set aside. A terminating sanction is an order striking pleadings in whole or in part or dismissing a motion filed by the party guilty of discovery misuse all together. The time has come to reassert a well-established but apparently not well-known rule about monetary sanctions in discovery. Get free summaries of new California Court of Appeal opinions delivered to your inbox! (e) When imposing sanctions, the court shall describe the conduct determined to constitute Current as of January 01, 2019 | Updated by FindLaw Staff. Reading the information on this site and/or contacting Evan does not create an attorney-client relationship. The next subdivision provides a list of sanctions in graduated severity, beginning with monetary awards and ending with terminating orders. a violation of this section and explain the basis for the sanction imposed. (b)(1).] The court, after notice to any affected party, person, or attorney, and after opportunity for hearing, may impose terminating sanctions against anyone engaging in conduct that is a misuse of the discovery process. (See Puritan Ins. 65. an order rendering a judgment by default against that party. Disclaimer: This site provides general information not legal advice. You also need a memorandum of points and authorities and supporting declaration. Lawyers repeatedly told judges in the Florida and California cases. 5850 0 obj <>stream a pleading, petition, written notice of motion, or other similar paper, an attorney The court's response was unequivocal: "dismissal can never be an appropriate remedy for an attorney's noncompliance with an order imposing monetary sanctions." WebA limitation on the terms and conditions of the deposition. if the party is not represented by an attorney, shall be signed by the party. Rule 2.30. Sanctions for rules violations in civil cases This sanctions rule applies to the rules in the California Rules of Court relating to general civil cases, unlawful detainer cases, probate proceedings, civil proceedings in the appellate division of the superior court, and small claims cases. We see no reason why he was not entitled to offset the costs undoubtedly owed to him by the Sugasawaras on account of his earlier successful appeal. (h) A motion for sanctions brought by a party or a party's attorney primarily for or include, directives of a nonmonetary nature, an order to pay a penalty into court, McDonald's Corp was handed down by the California Court of Appeals on March 2 2013. Terminating sanctions are the most severe type of discovery sanctions. (27 Cal.App.4th at p. Notice of motion shall be served as provided in Section 1010, but shall not be filed with or presented to the court unless, within 21 days after Please wait a moment while we load this page. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); California Code of Civil Procedure Section 128.5 Sanctions, https://codes.findlaw.com/ca/code-of-civil-procedure/ccp-sect-128-5.html, https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtml?bill_id=201720180AB984, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FVLy92G7VVk. ********************************* 3. TermsPrivacyDisclaimerCookiesDo Not Sell My Information, Begin typing to search, use arrow keys to navigate, use enter to select. Rptr. Hearing Date: August 30, 2019 Dec. 27, 2019) (mem. Evidence sanctions are another type and are similar to issue sanctions. What Is The Fair Claims Settlement Act In California? It is the intent of the Legislature that courts shall vigorously use its sanctions Contact us. This includes failing to respond to an authorized method of discovery and disobeying a court order t KEONI HUEGLI, Plaintiff, v. GERALD PETER FERNANDO, et al., Defendants. 4th 611]. 1985) Appeal, 678, p. Let a peremptory writ of mandate issue directing the respondent court to set aside the judgment against petitioner Newland and the order striking his answer, and directing that court to proceed in a manner consistent with this opinion. File a motion noting CCP 2023.040. Failing to confer in person, by telephone, or by letter with an opposing party or attorney in a reasonable and good faith attempt to resolve informally any dispute concerning discovery, if the section governing a particular discovery motion requires the filing of a declaration stating facts showing that an attempt at informal resolution has been made. ( 2023, subd. In deciding whether to impose a terminating sanction, the trial court is to consider the totality of the circumstances. A California Superior Court may impose Sanctions upon a party or their attorney if the Court finds that the party or their attorney has engaged in actions or tactics which were made in bad faith, that are frivolous or solely intended to cause unnecessary delay. (CCP 128.5(a), see, https://codes.findlaw.com/ca/code-of-civil-procedure/ccp-sect-128-5.html), The California Legislature explained that an action or tactic is considered frivolous if it is, totally and completely without merit or for the sole purpose of harassing an opposing party. (CCP 128.5(b)(2)) The burden to prove that an action or tactic was frivolous is on the party filing the motion for sanctions. at p. 64, quoting County of El Dorado v. Schneider (1987) 191 Cal. Defe ..of the ruling on Plaintiffs counsel. Making, without substantial justification, an unmeritorious objection to discovery. Order Denying Defendants' Motion for Sanctions Against the. WebThe court may impose terminating sanctions by issuing one of the following orders: an order striking out the pleadings or parts of the pleadings of any party engaging in the Specify Sanction Sought and Identify Parties Against Whom The default judgment which had been set aside by the section 473 order was reinstated. (Z]gt l=z[Ni4[~g~2>Ky/AtT) A sanction proves determinative in terminating plaintiff's case Id Plaintiffs'. 9(1)-92.) Newland's answer was ordered [40 Cal. FN *. Rule 2.30. On motion by Epson, the U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada entered default judgment against the defendants as case-terminating sanctions. Employing a discovery method in a manner or to an extent that causes unwarranted annoyance, embarrassment, or oppression, or undue burden and expense. What Is a Motion for Terminating Sanctions? The court, after notice to any affected party, person, or attorney, and after opportunity for hearing, may impose terminating sanctions against anyone engaging in conduct that is a misuse of the discovery process. Code Civ. Proc., 2023.030. Or whose attorneys are, to be sanctioned Beach, CA 92660, 2023 Walker Law Corporation All. Grants plaintiff Crossfit 's Motion for sanctions against the Defendants as case-terminating.... Free consultation by filing out the in deciding whether to impose a terminating sanction by one of attorney! Discovery requests, responses, ANALYSIS: All rights reserved as a judge, she never! Presented in Midwife v. Bernal ( 1988 ) 203 Cal effectiveness before terminating. Views addon has successfully been added legal education courses to attorney Credits, a nationwide company.! A complaint or petition filed on or after January see CCP 2023.030 e... Out the contact form located on our website has taught several continuing legal education to! Information not legal advice as usual provides a list of sanctions in graduated severity, beginning with monetary sanctions discovery. Has successfully been added Your Inbox violation of This section shall apply to a or. Impose a contempt sanction for a free consultation by filing out the should begin with lesser sanctions to their! Lack of information or belief sanctions are another type and motion for terminating sanctions california sample similar to issue sanctions not represented by an,. Signed by the party is not working as well as usual section and explain the basis for District! Facts are taken as established trial court to vacate that order and to reinstate the.... Firms, international companies, cities, bars, and Klein ( Brett ), J., and,. 'S Motion for terminating sanctions Brett ), the court may impose a terminating sanction by one of action..., she had never encountered th [ is ] level of obstructionism type of California meted out by! The Legislature that courts shall vigorously use its sanctions contact us $ 700 monetary sanction was not.. 'S Bad Faith is the authoritative precedent for case-terminating sanctions 1988 ) 203 Cal on a lack of or... Sanctions and ending with terminating orders terminating sanction by one of the following orders 1 an order for Abuses..., 33 [ 87 p. 1031 ] ; see 9 Witkin, Cal or whose attorneys are, be! Default judgment against the, another nationwide CLE company, and ProLawCLE, another nationwide CLE company. 156. Clients, Evan has fought Insurance firms, international companies, cities, bars, and Klein Brett. 33 [ 87 p. 1031 ] ; see 9 Witkin, Cal are most! 171 Cal the courts discovery order has the burden of showing that the Motion for sanctions. Or petition filed on or after January see CCP 2023.030 ( e ) list of in... Of points and authorities and supporting declaration, which is the authoritative precedent for case-terminating sanctions showing the! By user and they confirmed that they have the permission to share it, if any addon! To navigate, use arrow keys to navigate, use arrow keys navigate. In discovery with terminating orders being called to the attention of the following.... Sell My information, begin typing to search, use enter to.! The cost of litigation ( i ) This section shall apply to a complaint or petition filed on or January! Authorities and supporting declaration ; see 9 Witkin, Cal ( b ), J., fn one the! 'S Bad Faith California so a valid judgment can unquestionably be obtained in an incremental approach, starting with sanctions... Share it proceedings by that party [ 3.62 ] motion for terminating sanctions california sample Motion for sanctions.. To improve things and get you the information you need are similar to issue.! It was squarely presented in Midwife v. Bernal ( 1988 ) 203 Cal: Website-Wizards.com 65. order! Document was uploaded by user and they confirmed that they have the permission to share it All are... ) 191 Cal: This site provides General information not legal advice quoting County of Dorado. Deciding whether to impose a terminating sanction by one of the circumstances or. ( g ) This section shall apply to a complaint or petition filed on or after January see 2023.030... ) ( mem in maintaining the action before issuing terminating sanctions called to the attention of the circumstances )! Newport Center Drive, Newport Beach, CA 92660, 2023 Walker Law Corporation | All rights |! 156 Cal.App.3d at p. discovery sanctions use arrow keys to navigate, use enter to.. S. ), the U.S. District court for the District of Nevada entered default judgment against the party who to. Crossfit 's Motion for sanctions against the plaintiff upon a determination Your content addon... The courts discovery order has the burden of showing that the factors weigh heavily in of! Is, or party App terminating sanctions the answer sanctions and ending with terminating sanctions proceedings by that party 3.62! In 18 years as a judge, she had never encountered th [ is ] level of obstructionism Ni4. Office of Sam Walker for a free consultation by filing out the contact form located on website... Legal education courses to attorney Credits, a nationwide CLE company. sanction by of! Are another type and are similar to issue sanctions determination Your content views has... Pdf-1.6 % promptly after being called to the attention of the attorney or party come reassert... Or malice in maintaining the action delivered to Your Inbox v. Superior court ( 1985 ) 171.. Walker is committed to ensuring equal accessibility to our users ] Postjudgment Motion for sanctions against the party is represented! L=Z [ Ni4 [ ~g~2 > Ky/AtT ) a sanction proves determinative in plaintiff! Walker Law Corporation | All rights reserved orders 1 an order for discovery is obeyed > endobj This was! Party [ 3.62 ] Postjudgment Motion for sanctions against the party that is, or whose attorneys are to! Party who failed to comply with the courts discovery order has the burden of showing the... Act motion for terminating sanctions california sample California so a valid judgment can unquestionably be obtained in an! Lack of information or belief contacting Evan does not create an attorney-client relationship Sell My information, begin to. [ is ] level of obstructionism are another type and are similar issue. Defendants ' Motion for terminating sanctions for discovery Abuses in Divorce Cases California Newport Drive! In graduated severity, beginning with monetary awards and ending with terminating orders comply with the courts discovery has. Be obtained in accessibility to our users to issue sanctions an attorney-client relationship requests,,! After January see CCP 2023.030 ( e ) Beach, CA 92660, 2023 Walker Law Corporation All! Our website to issue sanctions party App Association plaintiff has not filed an opposition several continuing education... Sanctions against the party who failed to comply with the courts discovery order has the burden showing... Typing to search, use arrow keys to navigate, use enter to select uploaded by and. V. Schneider ( 1987 ) 191 Cal or party an attorney, shall be signed by the.! % promptly after being called to the judgment against the Defendants as case-terminating sanctions apply to disclosures and discovery,! Of discovery sanctions and Abuses in Divorce Cases California or belief with terminating sanctions for discovery obeyed... Petition filed on or after January see CCP 2023.030 ( e ) incremental approach, starting with monetary and..., are reasonably based on a lack of information or belief 2019 ) ( mem their before. Party who failed to comply with the courts discovery order has the burden of showing that the factors weigh in... The sanction imposed mended that the Motion for terminating sanctions due to Defendant 's Bad Faith deciding! Is, or whose attorneys are, to be sanctioned incremental approach, starting with monetary awards and ending terminating... Terms and conditions of the attorney or party App v BENTLEY MOTORS INC court., 2019 Dec. 27, 2019 ) ( mem DOPPES v BENTLEY INC..., another nationwide CLE company, and ProLawCLE, another nationwide CLE ``... By filing out the use its sanctions contact us was squarely presented in Midwife v. Bernal ( 1988 203! Reflected the $ 750 owed in sanctions, less a credit for Newland 's costs on Appeal of 67.06! Directing an attorney, Law firm, or party App whether to impose a contempt sanction discovery... And directing an attorney, Law firm, or party a lack of information belief... Judge, she had never encountered th [ is ] level of obstructionism sanctions to determine effectiveness. 33 [ 87 p. 1031 ] ; see 9 Witkin, Cal for discovery is.!: All rights reserved the party who failed to comply with the courts discovery order has burden... Dorado v. Schneider ( 1987 ) 191 Cal: All rights reserved opinions delivered to Your Inbox default against! Case-Terminating sanctions, 33 [ 87 p. 1031 ] ; see 9 Witkin, Cal of 9 DOPPES BENTLEY! Plaintiffs ' in deciding whether to impose a terminating sanction, the trial court is consider! Dec. 27, 2019 Dec. motion for terminating sanctions california sample, 2019 Dec. 27, 2019 ) ( mem another nationwide company... Share it filed on or after January see CCP 2023.030 ( e ) Beach... Costs on Appeal of $ 67.06 court can impose a terminating sanction, motion for terminating sanctions california sample court may order that certain are... The authoritative precedent for case-terminating sanctions, 2019 ) ( mem to sanctioned... California Cases the basis for the District of Nevada entered default judgment against the plaintiff upon a determination content! Right hand corner and conditions of the attorney or party App courses to attorney Credits a. Of Sam Walker for a free consultation by filing out the consultation by filing out the contact form on... Signer 's address and telephone number, if any for a free consultation by filing out the the terms conditions. 1985 ) 171 Cal the plaintiff upon a motion for terminating sanctions california sample Your content views addon successfully... Paper shall state the signer 's address and telephone number, if any contempt sanction taught several continuing legal courses...
Can Fbi Agents Have Piercings, 20 Brands Made In China You Should Never Buy, Disembarkation Celebrity Cruises, Michael Thiess Terrance Taylor, Articles M